Home  |   Blog  |  eNewsletter  |  Tools   Marketing Jobs / Marketing Careers   Bookstore  Search  |  Get Published  |  Feedback  |  Press  |  About MT   

  Marketing Today - The Online Guide to Marketing in the Information Age. Web Marketing, Internet Marketing, E-marketing, emarketing, I-marketing, Imarketing, Marketing Magazines, Marketing Ezines, Marketing Webzines, Marketing Magazines, Marketing Newsletters                
       Click here to find out more about Peter De Legge Consulting - Internet Marketing & Strategy Consulting Services - Visit: www.businessmarketing.net


 
Recommended by Harvard Business School's Working Knowledge, Northwestern University's Journal of Integrated Marketing Communications, Fast Company...    

Click here  to recommend Marketing Today to your colleagues. 

 
  The Online Guide to Marketing in the Information Age

      

Sections

Marketing Today - marketing, marketing communications, marcom, marcomm, integrated marketing communications Marketing
Marketing and marketing communications (offline and integrated)
Marketing Today - online marketing, internet marketing, e-marketing, emarketing, imarketing, i-marketing, cyber marketing Internet Marketing
Internet marketing and integrating offline and online marketing. Special section on Search Engine Marketing.
Marketing Today - online marketing, internet marketing, e-marketing, emarketing, imarketing, i-marketing, cyber marketing Trade Show Marketing / Event Marketing
Marketing at and managing trade shows and events.
Marketing Today - marketing research, marketing trends, marketing trend analysis, marketing studies, marketing research Research, Analysis and Trends
The latest data and analysis relevant to marketers
Marketing Today - marketing law, us marketing laws, european marketing laws, california marketing laws, email marketing laws, can-spam Marketing Law Resources
Marketing, advertising and email marketing related legal resources 
Marketing Today - public speaking and presentations Public Speaking & Presentations
Public speaking/ presentations
MarketingHire.com
Marketing Jobs / Marketing Careers 
Our marketing jobs / marketing career website, MarketingHire.com.
Marketing Today - the online guide to marketing in the information age News
Marketing news from more than 30 sources.
search engine marketing Search Engine Marketing
Search engine marketing and search engine optimization tools and advice.
Marketing Today - marketing tools, markeitng roi calculator (mroi), ad cpm calculator, marketing resources Marketing Tools
Direct Marketing ROI Calculator, Ad CPM Calculator and more
marketing book recommendations on marketing, marketing communications, business to business marketing / b2b marketing / btob marketing, marcom Marketing Bookstore  
Our Amazon.com bookstore contains or picks for the best marketing books. See our Marketing Book Recommendations
Marketing Today - search marketing articles, marketing tools, marketing book reviews and recommendations Marketing Events
Selected marketing events
Marketing Today - search marketing articles, marketing tools, marketing book reviews and recommendations Search
Search Marketing Today or the Web Using Google
Marketing Today - the online guide to marketing in the information age Home

Contribute/ Contact
Get published, send books for review, contact Peter DeLegge for media interviews or to speak at your event
About Marketing Today and Peter DeLegge
Add to My Yahoo!

Add Marketing Today Headlines and Article Summaries to Your My Yahoo! Page
Want to add Marketing Today headlines and summaries to your website, newsletter or blog? Click here

Get Marketing Today as an XML Feed! Feature  Marketing Today Headlines and Summaries on your website!
Add our RSS Newsfeed to your website for at no cost (approval required) click here for more information. 
Linking Policy
All content at this site is the property of Marketing Today. However, we permit linking to MarketingToday.com or directly to articles. We also allow approved* sites, blogs and email newsletters to use our article summaries AS-IS, without revision.
Click here for more information. 

Welcome to the Marketing Evolution...Marketing Today (tm)

 

Home > eMarketing

A Silver Lining on "YourCompanySucks.com" Sites
By John Brien

“There should be someone at every company whose job is to put into Google and blog search engines the name of the company or the brand, followed by the word ‘sucks,’ just to see what customers are saying.”
– Jeff Jarvis, author of the blog BuzzMachine, and president and creative director of newspaper publisher Advance Publications' Internet Division, as quoted in Fortune, January 10, 2005

We’ve all seen them – “[name of company] sucks” websites. Any organization can be hobbled with one. And it doesn’t take much to be placed on the hit list. You’d think the chief criterion would be your company’s widely acknowledged reputation as an irredeemable slime pit. No. All your company has to be is successful (i.e., have plenty of clients, a portion of whom are bound to be disgruntled). Not surprisingly, insurance companies are top targets.

As a marketer for XYZ Co., what do you do when you uncover an “XYZ sucks” site?

Sue

The first reaction is likely to be “Shut it down.” However, unless content is clearly libelous or defamatory, that may not be an option. In fact, seeking redress carries a number of negatives. Companies need to consider the legal costs but also the fallout – if the folks who run the “sucks” site catch the ear of reporters, the site gets free advertising in articles and your company gets depicted as Goliath stomping on David, validating claims about how bad you are. 

I know – it’s easy to say, “Claim the high ground. Assume a dignified stance. Don’t get in the mud with them.” And I agree – it’s not always advisable to lie down and take it; some situations merit a shock-and-awe response. We know of sites that, by any estimation, cross the line. One that springs to mind contains profiles (okay, dishes the dirt) on senior management.

When and how you react depends on your company’s pain threshold. Sites run the gamut from collecting/rehashing what’s available in the public domain to exposes rich in insider information, devoted to discrediting executives. (Warning: even when you think you have an open-and-shut case, the language on a “sucks” site may be sufficiently qualified or phrased in such a way that you can’t conclusively refute their interpretation.)

Of course, all it may take to get the “sucks” site to cease and desist is a letter from your attorney. But keep in mind – if these folks went to the trouble of launching and maintaining a website, they’re nursing quite a grudge. Be ready for a protracted battle, which means the “sucks” site remains live… and can turn more vitriolic. Again, legal action may play into your accuser’s hands, with the site operator(s) incited to escalate, welcoming an assault as a means to enhance their stature/further their cause.

Strike a Deal

In some cases, you may be able to buy the “sucks” site name. One company we know did just that. Astoundingly, they kept the site live… using it to direct visitors to the company’s official site. For many companies, silencing the offender in this way is an illusionary solution, like bowing to the demands of a blackmailer. The perpetrator can easily set up a site under a different name – or simply post to other sites – and continue to lambaste the company.  

Pay Attention

Late at night, the spectral “sucks” site hovers before your eyes. You thrash in bed, ruminations mercilessly circling in your head like the Muzak you hear when you’re put on hold. “That darn site is providing grist for the competition. Making us a laughingstock in the industry. Eroding our credibility with clients. Really miffing my boss.” 

Take heart. There is a positive side. You’re not alone.

You can take comfort in the fact that, like companies across the board, yours is being dissected – if not ridiculed – in other forums (if you don’t believe me, go to vault.com or google your company name along with “negligent” and “remiss”). It comes with living in an open society.

Give your clients credit.

In the same way that, invariably, major companies get sued, worldly clients will assume someone will be speaking ill of you. (In the B2B realm, client companies know from experience that getting raked over the coals is just part of being big.) The client forms its impression of you based on many factors – a “sucks” site is only one tile in a grand mosaic. Unless a lawsuit, or an on-line lashing, directly impacts their business dealings with you, a sensible client will treat a “sucks” site with a grain of salt.

What do you think will sway your client? Caustic comments from an anonymous source? Or a diet of “we know you” ingenuity and exceptional service? 

The bad sites are easily dismissed (by you as well as by current and prospective clients).

Many “sucks” sites have scant rhyme or reason, offering a mélange of “case studies,” examples, and accusations. Visitors grasp the tone after a single scroll – what’s initially intriguing reveals itself as the type of screed perfected by disaffected teens. (Besides confidentiality, there are plenty of reasons not to read your daughter’s diary – the entries tend to be uninformed, histrionic, and repetitive.) If the site features schoolyard gossip writ large, clients will simply “consider the source.”

In short: unless the site is truly clever or insightful – is doing more than merely funneling bile or common knowledge – even the most gullible visitor will quickly tire of it.

Note: For those wishing to build a “sucks” site, try focusing on a sound structure; an encyclopedic tack is about as effective as adding a dozen exclamation points after a sentence to make it more persuasive.  

The good sites are educational.
 
There you are. Face-to-face with XYZcompanysucks.com. You can’t ignore it. You can’t change it. Time to intone the Serenity Prayer?
 
Yes, but also time to rejoice. Don’t shun the site. Embrace it. Savor it. After all, you’re front row center at the “XYZ Company Roast.” Some companies would give their eyeteeth for such a fly-on-the-wall perspective. An unbridled view inside your critics’ minds (almost as good as reading your competitors’ e-mails). A resource more valuable, and much less expensive, than any market survey you could conduct.

Take a leisurely tour. You may be pleasantly surprised. Good sites contain a wealth of information including exhaustive archives, summaries of court judgments (with links!), and more. If it proves to be a valid clearinghouse of info (and can be easily navigated), it could become a favored destination for checking details on your organization…though, of course, you’d want to verify “facts” through another, more objective source.

Add the site to your informational arsenal. Make “sucks” a regular stop as you trawl the Web, not to police it (though it’s nice to be assured that the site is toeing the line) but in reviewing your company’s presence on the Net. 

As importantly, regard the site as a tool not for ravaging your company but for rectifying it (as I always say, “Your sharpest critic is your strongest ally”). As with survey findings, it’s incumbent upon you to pay attention to what the site says. Let’s face it – the site won’t be balanced, but those prickly contentions probably aren’t baseless (remember: where there’s smoke, there’s fire).

Separate the wheat from the chaff, And, where warranted, make improvements. Take a page from your crisis management book. That innocuous scoop on the “sucks” site could be a bomb fuse fizzing toward catastrophe. The last thing you want is for the CEO to stride into your office wondering why you didn’t inform him of it… and act on it.

*****

When you encounter a site attacking your company, it stirs a welter of emotions: a chill of disbelief, a flare of indignation, a dash of nausea. (The last time you felt this way, you found graffiti with your name on it.) But after a moment, you realize: the situation calls for a tempered assessment, not rash retaliation.

Practice a little stress management. Close your eyes. Breath in. Imagine the site’s mastermind simmering in a kettle of Wesson oil… or warm waves sweeping a tropical beach. And ask yourself: “Can my company stand up to the scrutiny?” If not, you have bigger issues than a “sucks” site. 


John Brien has an extensive marketing background encompassing marketing positions at Sears, Andersen Consulting, and Watson Wyatt Worldwide. He can be reached at jhn_brien@yahoo.com.

 Marketing Today - the online guide to marketing in the information age
© Copyright 2004, Peter DeLegge Consulting/Marketing Today. All rights reserved.

MarketingHire.com

Marketing jobs and career advice especially for marketers.

Quick Links to Marketing Job Searches:
- Marketing Director Jobs
- Marketing Manager Jobs
- VP Marketing Jobs
- Online Marketing Jobs
- Marketing Analyst Jobs
- Marketing Research Jobs
- Public Relations Jobs / PR Jobs
 

Subscribe to Marketing Today Newsletter FREE! 
Be alerted when new content is published, get exclusive newsletter-only articles and job listings. Join a virtual who's who of marketers from leading companies.

Subscribe

We do not rent or share our email list.

Marketing Today Blog
Frito-Lay and GM Get Integrated Marketing and Leverage the Power of Consumers in a Big Way
GM and Frito-Lay and their agencies have recently figured out a great way of getting consumers more engaged with their brands, leveraging the new found power of the consumer. It's a great lesson in integrated marketing communications and engagement for all marketers.Both brands are running contests for consumers to create homemade commercials (also referred to as consumer generated content) for
Marketing: The Art vs. Science Debate
I am amazed at how often we marketers debate over whether marketing is art or science. I was recently at a marketing association fund raising event where a speaker proclaimed that marketers are true artists, as if being artists validates our work. I thought, hmmm...Maybe that's part of the reason why CEOs and other departments think of marketers as lacking process and accountability, because we
Marketing Accountability on Another Level; Seth Godin's Profoundly Important Post
Seth Godin recently wrote a post on marketing ethics at his blog that has marketers talking. I applaud Seth's passion and his clever way of addressing marketing ethics in his book "All Marketers are Liars." It's a topic our profession needs to dialogue on and care about. I realize that business ethics books don't sell very well, so I'll keep this short and hope you'll look at Seth's post.
Can a Blog, Long Neglected, Be Resuscitated? My Re-Entry Into the Blogosphere
It's common blogosphere wisdom that to keep a blog alive, you need to keep to a rigorous publishing schedule. Well, if you've kept up with my blog, or even if you haven't and you notice the dates of previous posts, we're about to put that assumption to a test, as I make my re-entry into the blogosphere.But first, a little disclosure. For those cynics out there, you may see this (perhaps,
Speaking at BtoB's NetMarketing Breakfast Thursday in Chicago - Oct 6 - Here's $10 Off
Forgive the self-promotion, but I'll be speaking and participating in a roundtable at Crain's BtoB's NetMarketing Breakfast in Chicago this Thursday, October 6th. I've been strugling between two presentations, one regarding a significant study that breaks apart and measures each vehicle of marketing campaigns -- television, print, Internet, search engine marketing, radio spots, etc.; the other
Google Launches Google Blog Search
It was only a matter of time. Google has been promising blog search for a couple of years. Finally, this morning they rolled out a blog search engine capability. Not surprisingly, it’s labeled “beta.”According to a Google, “The goal of Blog Search is to include every blog that publishes a site feed (either RSS or Atom).” It looks for sites that update pinging services and crawls in real-time.
Disintegrated Marketing...
After more than a decade experience with the commercial web, you’d think major marketers would consider the web more than an afterthought. However, evidence reveals many consumer marketers still can’t distinguish between a website, an ad or a brochure. While retailers like Wal-Mart, Lowes, Nordstrom and Circuit City get it, there are others that still seem confused. When clothing retailer Gap
Burger King Goes Tasteless
Shock value is the refuge of the talentless when it comes to advertising and viral marketing. Burger King has decided to one-up Carl Jr.'s Paris Hilton raunch, by creating a series of over-the-top raunchy commercials and a website to promote a fictitious band called Coq Roq -- filled with bad double entendres. And while Carl Jr. is a small brand that can thrive by staying in the niches, Burger
Search Engine Marketing Secrets Revealed, Email Marketing Secrets, Direct Marketing Secrets...Apparently Marketers are Lousy at Keeping Secrets
A quick perusal through my email inbox reveals dozens of messages from companies touting for pay articles, books, seminars and papers on every topic known to marketing all claiming to possess "secrets."I checked a few out recently and was amazed to learn that things I've considered fairly common knowledge among those experienced with online marketing are actually secrets! Things like Google
"Those Who Ignore History are Destined to Repeat It" Applies to Marketing Too
One of the great lessons of the dot com era was that you can’t buy your way into a successful brand with mere dollars and awareness. After all, awareness doesn’t equal preference or sales. Those who attempted to “build their brand at breakneck speed” only ended up breaking their brand’s neck. Great brands are not built from ad dollars, although there are always marketing and advertising
RSS integration by RSSinclude

Marketing Today
Recommendations

Academia
"Recommended
."
- Harvard Business School (Working Knowledge)
- Northwestern University, Medill School

Noted Marketing Pros

"I love the site!"
Seth Godin, author, Permission Marketing

Chosen
As one of the "best business links on the web."
-
Business 2.0 Magazine's Web Guide

"Websites worth watching."
- Folio Magazine

Most importantly, our readers


Marketing Today (tm) - The Online Guide to Marketing in the Information Age
© Copyright 1997 - 2007, Peter DeLegge Consulting/Marketing Today. All rights reserved. Marketing Today and MarketingToday.com are trademarks owned by Peter DeLegge. "Welcome to the Marketing Evolution," copyright 1998, Peter DeLegge.